Indie Book Review: The Art of the Imperfect, a murder mystery set in Scarborough by Kate Evans

Kate E BookThe Art of the Imperfect, a murder mystery set in Scarborough by Kate Evans
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Disclaimer: I received a free electronic copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.

The Art of the Imperfect, a murder mystery set in Scarborough by Kate Evans follows the lives of characters in a seaside town after the murder of a well-known psychotherapist, Dr. Greene. While the novel certainly is a murder mystery, as a fair portion of the plot revolves around solving Dr. Greene’s murder, the reader should note that the novel is more than just a crime novel. In fact, I daresay this novel may not be for fans of dark, gritty, police procedural novels. The purpose of the novel lies much more in how Dr. Greene’s murder affects the residents of Scarborough and the way their lives intertwine because of the crime.

The Art of the Imperfect has multiple narrators, but the protagonist is Hannah, the woman who first discovers Dr. Greene’s corpse. Despite training to be a counselor herself, Hannah struggles with depression and possibly a bit of post-traumatic stress after the experience. The reader watches, as if from the outside, as Hannah battles her own insecurity, her inability to trust and connect with others, family problems, and darker demons that lurk within her psyche.

The other primary narrators of The Art of the Imperfect are Detective Sargeant Theo Akande, who is investigating Dr. Greene’s death, and Aurora, a solicitor who is experiencing postpartum depression. Theo seems to be the most reliable narrator, and the reader follows him on the journey to solve Dr. Greene’s murder, which hits numerous dead ends and reveals more unreliable suspects. Aurora, who happened to be my favorite character, believes her husband may be Dr. Greene’s killer. Evans writes Aurora’s passages poetically and with some of the most unique descriptions I have read. It is through Aurora’s eyes that the language truly shines.

Given the various and psychologically unstable characters, the plot of The Art of the Imperfect is a bit difficult to follow. I found it difficult to separate the facts from the delusions, which at times made me lose focus on the action and left me uncertain as to who actually killed Dr. Greene. For me, the murder mystery itself was the weakest part of the novel, but the characters and their fascinating journeys made up for it. (On a cultural note, I should also add that, as an American, I did not know all of the abbreviations used and places referred to, which may have taken some of the depth of the novel away from me.)

Overall, The Art of the Imperfect is a beautifully-written psychological journey into the minds of characters after a trauma. The way Evans writes from unstable perspectives is poetic, and the way she interwove the lives of the characters is clever. While I found the actual crime mystery lacking, Evans more than makes up with it with her language and understanding of the human mind. I recommend this novel to anyone interested in psychology, psychological issues, and light crime.

View all my reviews

Kate E BookIf you are interested in reading The Art of the Imperfect and would like to help sponsor my writing and research, you can purchase it at my Amazon Associates Store. By doing this, you will not pay a cent extra, nor will the author receive a cent less, but I will receive a small commission on the sale. Simply click the book’s title or the book’s image.


Kate M. Colby is an author of science fiction, fantasy, and nonfiction. When she is not writing or working, Kate enjoys playing video games, antiquing, and wine tasting. She lives in the United States with her husband and furry children.

Tagged with: , , , , , , , , ,
Posted in Book Reviews, Fiction Blog
5 comments on “Indie Book Review: The Art of the Imperfect, a murder mystery set in Scarborough by Kate Evans
  1. I’m interested in why this book is set in Scarborough. I’m setting my next novel in Scarborough, a Victorian seaside town in the north of England which I know well. It’s a very characterful place, so does that fact play a significant part in the story?

    Liked by 1 person

    • For me, the location did not seem to have a significant impact on the plot. If I’m remembering correctly, I believe Kate Evans is from Scarborough, so my assumption is she set the novel there out of fondness and/or familiarity.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. […] The Art of the Imperfect, a murder mystery set in Scarborough by Kate Evans – read review […]


  3. […] on her newest book The Art of Survival (follow up to The Art of the Imperfect, which I reviewed here). Over to Kate […]


  4. […] The Art of Breathing by Kate Evans is a crime fiction novel and the third installment in the Scarborough Mysteries series. It follows the lives of Hannah Poole, Detective Sargent Theo Akande, and Aurora Harris as they navigate mental health and family issues, as well as investigate crimes in their small town. Because this is the third book in a series, I’ll keep some aspects of my review vague to avoid spoiling details from the first two novels. You can read my review of The Art of the Imperfect (Scarborough Mysteries #1) here. […]


Share Your Thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Fiction Fans: Join My Reader List

Two emails a month with...
1) Sneak peeks of new books
2) Behind-the-scenes content
3) First notice on special deals


Get your FREE booklet
100 Blogging Ideas for Fiction Writers

SIGN UP for my Writing Newsletter today!

Buy Signed Books
Click the Books tab on the menu
What I’m Reading
Tweet Me
My Instagram Feed
Our final road trip adventure: returning to Salem! This time, my highlight was visiting the probable burial site of Rebecca Nurse.
%d bloggers like this: